These days whenever the subject of masculinity is brought up, it’s within a negative context. In the media men are either presented as violent thugs, feckless morons or as utilities with no feelings of there own. The only time masculinity is spoken about is when some psychopath attacks women and then we’re expected to believe that this behaviour is representative or encouraged by the average man.
We don’t hold women to account in the same way. When a female teacher “has an affair” with an underage student, or when a woman kills her own children, we don’t hear a collective outcry demanding that all women must be held accountable for this particular woman’s crime. Even getting it acknowledged as a crime, and seeing a woman as anything other than a helpless victim can sometimes feel like an uphill battle.
There are no shortage of calls to action for men to change, whether it be Gillette razor adverts, “don’t be that guy“, MPs suggesting that men should be curfewed or even young boys being asked to stand up and apologise to their female class mates for the horrific crime of being born male.
I don’t recognise a need for men in general to continue to beat themselves up over what outliners do. I believe that the majority of men, although not perfect, are decent people just trying to live their lives the best way they can. They’re no more demonic than women and no more capable of doing horrible things. Dare I say it, men are good.
So, it got me thinking, what is it that I think of when I think about what masculinity looks like. Of course, masculinity, just like femininity will mean different things to different people but to me there couldn’t be anything more quintessentially masculine than the story of Chris Gardner, as portrayed in the Will Smith film, “In the pursuit of happyness“.
If you haven’t seen the film, I recommend you give it a try. Warning, the rest of this article discusses the plot so stop reading here if you want to see it for yourself first.
Gardner’s story was one of adversity and perseverance. He had a partner and young child that he was trying to support and he put all his money into a medical device similar to a portable x-ray machine, but despite his best efforts, he was struggling to sell the units.
Immediately I identified with that willingness men have to gamble and take risks for the prospect of a better future. We owe everything to men, like Gardner, that are willing to take chances, it has brought us so much technology and made everybody’s lives significantly easier than our ancestors but people take it for granted, not realising that for every successful inventor or entrepreneur that there are thousands and thousands that don’t make that breakthrough.
Chris didn’t give up though. He saw the success of stockbrokers in San Francisco and decided for himself that he was going to make a better life for his family. The people that are successful are not the ones that sit back and just hope that something will happen to them, they’re the people that go out and are willing to make doors open for themselves. There’s no guarantee of success but there is a guarantee that if you always do what you always did, you will always get what you always got.
It got to a stage where Chris ended up as a single parent. His partner, fed up of his continued struggle to provide upped and left but Chris refused to allow her to take his son with her. In a way this was a stroke of fortune here because for many men, they are completely powerless to stop their co-parent taking away their children and the impact is devastating to both the father and the child. In fact, it was Gardner’s experience of not having his own father around that made him so determined to be there for his own little boy.
In a state of desperation, after the pair were kicked out of their apartment, Chris approached a women’s shelter where he was told that he could leave the boy there but no men were allowed. This was the 1980s but I have heard stories from men escaping domestic violence at the hands of female perpetrators and sadly, little has changed, which is why fathers are so reluctant to leave their abusers. They would rather take the beatings than have to remove themselves from their children.
Life was tough and the pair ended up homeless on the street, in one heart-breaking scene they were forced to sleep inside the public toilets in a railway station but as long as they were together, it did not matter.
It is hard not to see the love and the kindness Chris had towards his son and to Christopher junior, his dad was his hero. He taught him how to play basketball, he taught him never to let anyone else tell him what he could and could not do. He was a role model in every sense of the word and I think we really aught to be acknowledging fatherhood and how important it is for the development of children right now. Masculinity does not need to become feminine, masculine energy is already kind, loving and selfless, just like femininity can be but in it’s own unique way.
Chris worked an unpaid internship for six months, just about scraping by selling the last of his medical devices, never complaining about his situation, always working hard and putting on a brave face for his boy and though his intelligence, ingenuity, hard work and sheer determination, got the one paid role on offer amongst his cohort of 20.
He eventually went on to be very successful, forming his own company and selling the last of his stake in 2006.
Today we are told that aggression is bad, but aggression is not the same thing as violence. Aggression is essential for men, whether it’s aggressively pursuing a career, refusing to take no for an answer or to protect your loved ones. The world can be a hard place and were giving young men the wrong message if we’re going to tell them it’s wrong to be aggressive. The opposite of aggression is not kindness, it’s being passive and being passive results in bad outcomes for men.
The same with stoicism. The harsh reality is men’s pain is taboo. The world wants men that are sensitive to the feelings of others but they do not want men that fall apart in times of crisis. Stoicism is what gets you through those tough times. Stoicism does not mean that you do not have feelings, nor does it mean that you do not express them but there are different ways to express feelings and one way that works particularly well for men is through action and problem solving rather than obsessing over the feelings themselves. This is a healthy way to deal with issues but as the number of masculine environments have been eroded, so has our understanding of the age old art of healing this way.
Still, there is the softer side of men that people don’t talk about. The way men will put other people’s needs first. The way that they want to provide and protect for their families. Men are essential to society and a society that turns its back on men is one that will soon collapse so stop honouring men at your peril.
There will be people that here me talk about these positive masculine traits and what they will hear is not the positive thing that I’m saying about men but they will assume that if I’m saying men are all these things then it must mean that women can’t have similar qualities too.
For those people, I ask you to think about this, if I say an owl is great at flying, does it mean that a humming bird cannot fly? No, of course not. Of course an owl and a humming bird fly in different ways, unique to them but they are both flying birds.
Nor am I saying that every single owl can fly, some have broken wings, some have had their wings clipped and I think a lot of men are in that situation and need to heal in order to reconnect with that powerful masculine energy.
If your first reaction when you hear a positive account of men is either defensive or denial, you should probably consider think about what is causing those insecurities and how you can address those issues.
Men are great, masculinity is a precious and beautiful gift. Women are also great, and femininity is also a very beautiful thing. At the minute both are under attack. Let’s stop the attack and start the mutual admiration, the dance as old as time that has kept humanity moving forward.